Gear Reviews

I've found a startling lack of good outdoor gear reviews on the web. Here's what I know and use. If you find it useful, drop me a line. Note: a lot of this information was woefully out of date, so I've deleted some and modified others. There are lots of other items on which I have strong opinions at the moment, but I haven't found time or energy to review them yet.

Contents

Camping and General Gear
  • CAMP XLC470 Crampons
  • CAMP Altitude / XLA210 Ice Axe
  • Sherpa Climber Snowshoes
  • MSR Denali Snowshoes
  • Montrail Moraine AT Hiking Boots
  • Leki Super Makalu Hiking Poles
  • Lowe Alpine Outback 70 Backpack
  • MSR Dragonfly Stove
  • TNF Cats Meow Sleeping Bag
  • Climbing Gear
  • Active Protection (various)

  • General Hiking and Camping Gear

    CAMP XLC Crampons -- When I bought these in 2004, they were the lightest 12-point crampons in the world (all of 470 grams) and they may still be. I've used them on a number of snow climbs in Colorado and they have performed fairly well. The downside is that they are aluminum and don't hold an edge. Yes, I have done technical ice in these things, but I definitely wouldn't recommend it. Flexing, dull frontpoints do not inspire confidence. Nor are they ideal for kicking steps in steep, hard snow. However, for their intended purpose, they work very well; moderate snow climbs where strong and sharp points are not required. I use the hybrid binding system (universal front, step-in rear, the XLC470 model) which attach to my heavy hiking boots. In retrospect, I wish I'd gone with the strap-on model so I could use them with lighter footwear.
    CAMP Altitude Ice Axe -- This has been my main axe for three years now. It is very light and has served me well, but, as my mountaineering level increases, I begin to see it's limitations. The pick is fairly short compared with comparable axes and self arrests are not quite as secure as they could be. The adze is similarly small and not really suitable for chopping away ice. The aluminum spike is marvelously light, but can't be sharpened and won't penetrate hard snow when you need it most. After three seasons of hard use, the rivet holding the spike to the shaft sheared away. I note with interest that CAMP now features steel spikes on many of their axes. Still, this axe is great for what it was designed for: moderate snow slopes, glissades, and traverses. My needs have outgrown my axe. Amy has the freakishly light (9 oz) XLA210 which is identical except that it has an aluminum head (and is 10cm shorter).
    Sherpa Climber Snowshoes -- Big, stompy snowshoes (8x30"). I've used these in various conditions now from deep powder to packed trails and found them to be good but not ideal. Flotation is excellant and the nylon-wrapped frame gives a little more purchase when going uphill or down. However, they don't traverse well and tend to slip latterally. The metal bar hinge lets them rotate freely and stay parallel to the ground. The big, aluminum cleats on the bottom provide ridiculous grip on packed snow, but tend to ball up at the slightest provocation. The binding system is lovely and simple and is a breeze to put on. Requires periodic tightening, but that's life. The downsides are that they're big enough, they're hard to carry on my pack. Also, the bindings are such that my toes tend to ride up over the aluminum toe bar and catch on the decking material. I have solved this with a metal strap from the front of the toe bar to the webbing across my insteps. Note: Sherpa appears to be out of business now, so these may become collectors items, of a sort.
    MSR Denali Classic Snowshoes -- I got these last season to replace my failing Sherpas. They are a very different paradigm with the plastic decks, but seem to be the standard around here for winter mountaineering. They are smaller and lighter than my old Sherpas, but climb much better, are much simpler, and traverse very well. The downside is that they are loud and have much less flotation than larger shoes. I own flotation tails for them, but have yet to try them out. Another advantage is that they are much cheaper than most other snowshoes out there.
    Montrail Moraine Boots -- I owned a pair of these from 1996 when Montrail was still OneSport and loved them dearly. They fit straight out of the box and provided ample support over hill and dale, ice and scree for seven years. In 2003, they finally split down the middle of the sole (!!!) and had to be retired. I replaced them with the updated model which is considerably beefier and heavier duty than the old version. I'll admit that these boots may not be for everyone; they are quite heavy and entirely more macho than neccessary for simple hiking and most anything out east in the summer. Here in Colorado, I've found them to be good off-trail hikers in the summer, good in snow and even for moderate mountaineering. They are stiff enough for flexible crampons and step-kicking, yet flexible enough for hiking comfortably for short trail distances (less than 10 miles). The new versions have a heel bail for crampons (see above) and a plastic tongue plate to spread the load out on the foot. Other peoples' reviews have been decidedly mixed, but they fit my medium width, high arch, medium volume feet quite well. Technically, they edge like demons on steep rock and are fairly warm. I have lead up to 5.6 in them without much fear. Now the downsides: they are hideously uncomfortable for long days of flat trail.
    Leki Super-Makalu Hiking Poles -- I've been using these poles for a decade now and have almost no complaints. Now on my second pair, they have saved my bacon a number of times both figuratively and litterally. My only complaint is that the locking mechanism sometimes won't lock without a good deal of finagling (the BD system may be superior in this regard). Worth every penny and ounce. I recently retired my old poles and purchased the updated version. The shocks now have two settings and the straps are more easily adjustable. Other than that, they are the same great poles.
    Lowe Alpine Outback-70 Backpack -- They don't make this pack anymore which is extremely unfortunate. It is a no-frills, light-weight internal frame pack perfect for my needs and a pleasent purple color to boot. The sleeping bag compartment on the bottom is separated from the main compartment by a zippered divider. The suspension system is nicely adjustable without being extremely heavy. The hip belt is not as padded as some folks might like and the stuffing in the butt pad has shifted around a bit. You've got to pack a little carefully or else sharp things in the pack can poke through into your back, but it is otherwise completely worth it. I've humped this pack over 500 Appalachian Trail miles and across four continents (those being Africa, Europe, and the Americas). I've seen several thru-hikers on the AT with the same or similar packs and they were still having a good time as far north as New Hampshire.
    MSR Dragonfly Stove -- This is the Cadillac of white-gas stoves. It's heavy and expensive, but cooks beautifully and reliably. The simmer option really does work and I can get a flame anywhere in the range of silent candle flame to roaring jet engine easily and with great finesse. The disadvantages are, obviously, that it's heavy and expesive, and that it must be coddled a bit when turning it on. You have to prime it carefully: let a little fuel out into the bottom and burn it. When the fuel has practically burned away, open the valve slightly and start cooking. You have to turn it up slowly or else you get exciting fuel-air fireballs which shoot out. Takes about thirty seconds to warm up properly but performs like a champ after that. I don't usually take it when I'm out by myself, but it does nicely for group trips where gourmet cooking is a higher priority.

    There is a new stove (the Simmerlite?) put out by MSR which is similar to the Dragonfly in terms of cooking control, but about 1/3rd the weight. If I were to get a new stove today, it would probably be something like this. Update: the weakness of this stove (and many MSR stoves, I suspect) is the plastic pump. I've broken two pumps now which leads to various blue language in the backcountry.

    TNF Cats Meow Sleeping Bag -- Pros: light, comfortable. Cons: doesn't even come close to the advertised 20-degree temperature rating and doesn't hold it's loft after even moderate use. Anything even approaching freezing than freezing and I'm left wishing I'd brought my down bag. This may be partially my fault as I left it in its sack for a solid month during a trip to Patagonia and the fill has noticably compressed. But I know half a dozen other people with this bag and they all hate it. At this point, this is my summer bag and I'll bring my down for anything in the other three seasons.

    Rock Climbing Gear

    I've been
    rock climbing for about 10 years now (mostly easy trad) and have built up a moderately-formidable stash of gear; probably too much to review here! In any case, I'll mention some of the more major purchase items.
    Active Protection -- I'm a fan of Black Diamond Camalots and most of them between the 0.3 finger crack size up to an old style (C2?) 3.5 rattly fist size. They're a bit more expensive and heavier than other cams, but the double axle design gives them a much wider expansion range per unit. Not knowing what I'm going to face on any given lead, I'd rather have four camalots than the six units of another brand covering the same range (and costing about the same amount). Here's a brief cam size comparison page. While we're on the subject of gear, I favor BD hardware in general using a set of their Stoppers and Hexcentrics. Add to this a handful of the smaller CAMP Tricams and you've got my basic trad rack.

    Other Gear Reviews


    Charles Danforth
    Last modified: Sun Jul 5 09:37:42 MDT 2009